Whilst I appreciate the sentiment behind this, it is really flawed for several reasons:
- Not all rapists have testicles.
- Rape is not normally motivated by a person having a high/uncontrollable sex drive. Castration will not change the need for power and control that usually does motivate rapists.
- Castrating someone is probably going to make them rather angry, and this is likely to exacerbate the feelings that make them want to rape in the first place. What’s more, a lot of male rapists are motivated by feelings of emasculation. So, yeah, castrating someone like that is actually rather risky.
- Castration doesn’t address what predominantly underpins sexual violence in society: proprietory attitudes towards women, rape culture, misogyny, etc.
- It’s naive to think that sexual behaviour is entirely governed by hormones.
- It is still possible to offend when chemically castrated.
Whilst castration can be effective for a minority of offenders (some actually request they be castrated, and I have no issue with this) the vast majority will be unaffected or will possibly become more motivated to offend. Surely that’s something nobody wants.
Yes, I am aware that there are a handful of studies which show these drugs to be effective at reducing recidivism. However, researching this is inherently flawed and problematic. Firstly, it’s not possible to have a control group because the effects of the drug are so obvious. What’s more, offenders who know they are being monitored for research are more like to be on their “best behaviour”. Not to mention that the kind of offender who volunteers for treatment is also likely to be more responsive to that treatment - whatever form it takes - because they have the motivation to change.
I’ll end with a quote from Frances Crook of the Howard League For Penal Reform:
Sex offending is often not about sex at all, but about violence and domination. The [chemical castration] drugs used will not affect those attitudes. Some men may inflict other types of deviant behaviour on victims if they are unable to perform sexually due to the drugs. The physical impact of the drugs can be very powerful, with the effect being similar to a sex change. ”Feminising” sex offenders may make it more difficult for these individuals to reintegrate into society, which in turn makes their reoffending more likely.
I also think it’s also rather problematic to be using testosterone blockers as a form of punishment, particularly when considered in light of trans people who have to constantly fight for access similar forms of medication. It’s a massive problem that cis people are gatekeepers to medicine that trans women often want and can’t get. And it’s kinda fucked up to be using that same medicine as a way of punishing the most deviant members of society (made worse when you consider the way trans people are routinely cast as deviant or perverted themselves). I dunno, I can’t really articulate this point well, but it makes me really uncomfortable.
-
caerabear reblogged this from poweradepuke
-
skeletonxcity likes this
-
poweradepuke reblogged this from lionheartedskinhead
-
another-cool-kid reblogged this from dead-end-journey
-
dead-end-journey reblogged this from jetsonlazars
-
this-sweet-venom likes this
-
the-patron-saint-of-lost-causes reblogged this from agentvenomranger
-
firefly-in-the-dark likes this
-
dennyorange reblogged this from glittershotgun and added:
ABSOLUTELY SICK AND DISGUSTING THING TO DO TO ANYONE!!!!
-
crayonaize likes this
-
yerbird likes this
-
causethegooddieyoung likes this
-
shortietheatrekid reblogged this from glittershotgun
-
humptytumbly likes this
-
jetsonlazars reblogged this from agentvenomranger
-
notchantelle likes this
-
mynieceisaslut reblogged this from agentvenomranger
-
mynieceisaslut likes this
-
agentvenomranger reblogged this from sleepless-in-chicago
-
sleepless-in-chicago reblogged this from theoryofablackbird
-
cunafish likes this
-
ayyiyi likes this
-
j0nz likes this
-
atimbalance likes this
-
smoothfruitcakejewbrokandikid likes this
-
tailypo-tailypo likes this
-
champagne-fountain reblogged this from theoryofablackbird
-
theoryofablackbird reblogged this from glittershotgun
-
lessauvages likes this
-
glittershotgun reblogged this from glittershotgun and added:
5EVER
-
laverdadvencera likes this
-
hussardcore likes this
-
jai-liftingweight likes this
-
misandryisalie likes this
-
kusifisti reblogged this from disgustingooze
-
misanthropic-cacophony likes this
-
unit-025 reblogged this from liberteeny and added:
I think that people should be given the opportunity to get chemically castrated if they think they have impulses that...
-
unit-025 likes this
-
liberteeny reblogged this from haereticum
-
saltymrshotgun likes this
-
genusssucht likes this
-
kmfcm reblogged this from oneconcernedman
-
oneconcernedman reblogged this from nerdymouse
-
oneconcernedman likes this
-
burymewithmybass reblogged this from tragedy-in-a-kids-meal
-
fouipin likes this
-
aseriousbibliophile reblogged this from proudinsufferableknowitall
-
reptileally likes this
-
thisismymoon reblogged this from kissyouineyegulps and added:
excellent commentary.
- Show more notes
![Whilst I appreciate the sentiment behind this, it is really flawed for several reasons:
Not all rapists have testicles.
Rape is not normally motivated by a person having a high/uncontrollable sex drive. Castration will not change the need for power and control that usually does motivate rapists.
Castrating someone is probably going to make them rather angry, and this is likely to exacerbate the feelings that make them want to rape in the first place. What’s more, a lot of male rapists are motivated by feelings of emasculation. So, yeah, castrating someone like that is actually rather risky.
Castration doesn’t address what predominantly underpins sexual violence in society: proprietory attitudes towards women, rape culture, misogyny, etc.
It’s naive to think that sexual behaviour is entirely governed by hormones.
It is still possible to offend when chemically castrated.
Whilst castration can be effective for a minority of offenders (some actually request they be castrated, and I have no issue with this) the vast majority will be unaffected or will possibly become more motivated to offend. Surely that’s something nobody wants.
Yes, I am aware that there are a handful of studies which show these drugs to be effective at reducing recidivism. However, researching this is inherently flawed and problematic. Firstly, it’s not possible to have a control group because the effects of the drug are so obvious. What’s more, offenders who know they are being monitored for research are more like to be on their “best behaviour”. Not to mention that the kind of offender who volunteers for treatment is also likely to be more responsive to that treatment - whatever form it takes - because they have the motivation to change.
I’ll end with a quote from Frances Crook of the Howard League For Penal Reform:
Sex offending is often not about sex at all, but about violence and domination. The [chemical castration] drugs used will not affect those attitudes. Some men may inflict other types of deviant behaviour on victims if they are unable to perform sexually due to the drugs. The physical impact of the drugs can be very powerful, with the effect being similar to a sex change. ”Feminising” sex offenders may make it more difficult for these individuals to reintegrate into society, which in turn makes their reoffending more likely.
I also think it’s also rather problematic to be using testosterone blockers as a form of punishment, particularly when considered in light of trans people who have to constantly fight for access similar forms of medication. It’s a massive problem that cis people are gatekeepers to medicine that trans women often want and can’t get. And it’s kinda fucked up to be using that same medicine as a way of punishing the most deviant members of society (made worse when you consider the way trans people are routinely cast as deviant or perverted themselves). I dunno, I can’t really articulate this point well, but it makes me really uncomfortable.](http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m4ydxrl8zK1rskw3lo1_500.jpg)